Magic Mushroom Identification

Learning how to identify magic mushrooms correctly is a crucial skill for anyone hoping to pick them in the wild. After all, making a mistake could lead to serious illness or even death.

Unfortunately, many magic mushrooms are what mycologists refer to as LBMs or little brown mushrooms. To the untrained eye, they can be challenging to distinguish from other LBMs, including poisonous species.

However, identifying magic mushrooms is actually relatively straightforward once you know their key characteristics. This guide explains what you need to know before foraging for magic mushrooms, including where to find them, how to recognize them, and their most common look-alikes.

Try 100% LEGAL Amanita Gummies!

Want to experience the ‘magic’ of the Amanita muscaria mushroom? Iconic U.S. brand VidaCap has just launched a new range of 500mg Amanita gummies that soothe the mind and harmonize both body and spirit. Try them today and get 25% OFF all orders with WayofLeaf’s exclusive coupon code: AMANITAWOL

Apply 25% Coupon

Magic Mushroom Identification 101

Identifying magic mushrooms is, in essence, similar to identifying any other fungi. It is necessary to consider several critical features, including:

• Region and climate
• Season
• Habitat
• Growth pattern (habit)
• Physical characteristics
  • Cap
  • Stem
  • Gills
• Color changes
• Spores

It is also essential for would-be foragers to familiarize themselves with potential magic mushroom look-alikes in their area. The importance of this cannot be overstated since some psychedelic mushroom species have deadly poisonous look-alikes. Invest in a good field guide with plenty of photos or, better still, take a course with an experienced mycologist.

How to Identify Magic Mushrooms by Region and Climate

There are many magic mushroom varieties, and some prefer a specific region or climate. Knowing which mushrooms grow where you live will help you narrow down the species you will likely find there.

For example, if you live in Wisconsin, you are unlikely to find tropical species such as Psilocybe cubensis growing in nature. Therefore, you will be better served by learning to identify temperate species like Psilocybe semilanceata and Psilocybe cyanescens.

Below, we have listed which magic mushroom species you are most likely to find in each region and climate.

Magic Mushroom Species by Region and Climate

North-East USA (Humid Continental Climate)

• Psilocybe caerulipes
• Psilocybe ovoideocystidiata

North-West USA, Pacific North-West USA, South-East Australia, Northern Europe (Temperate-Oceanic Climate)

• Psilocybe allenii
• Psilocybe azurescens
• Psilocybe baeocystis
• Psilocybe cyanescens
• Psilocybe pelliculosa
• Psilocybe semilanceata
• Psilocybe stuntzii
• Psilocybe subaeruginosa

South-East USA, Central America, North-East Australia (Humid Subtropical/Tropical Climate)

• Panaeolus cyanescens
• Psilocybe cubensis
• Psilocybe tampanensis

South-West USA, Southern Europe (Mediterranean Climate)

• Psilocybe allenii
• Psilocybe cyanescens
• Psilocybe ovoideocystidiata
• Psilocybe stuntzii

Central America, South America (Tropical Wet and Dry Climate)

• Panaeolus cyanescens
• Psilocybe caerulescens
• Psilocybe cubensis
• Psilocybe mexicana

Magic Mushroom Season

Magic mushrooms tend to grow seasonally. Like all mushrooms, they prefer damp and humid conditions. Therefore, many species appear during the fall when rainfall increases. They may also reappear during the spring.

However, magic mushrooms can grow during other seasons in tropical and subtropical climates. For example, some tropical species, such as Psilocybe cubensis, fruit most heavily during the hottest months.

The Six Magic Mushroom Habitats

According to leading mycologist Paul Stamets, there are six classic magic mushroom habitats:

Grassland

This habitat includes meadows, cow and sheep pastures, lawns, roadsides, and playing fields. Various Psilocybe species grow here, including P. semilanceata, P. strictipes, P. liniformans, P. tampanensis, and P. mexicana. These mushrooms tend to appear in areas of longer, unmown grass.

Woodland

Many species grow in this habitat, feeding on decaying matter such as wood debris, fallen logs, and tree stumps. The species found here will vary depending on the type of woodland (mixed, deciduous, coniferous), climate, and altitude. Some “wood lovers” also grow prolifically on woodchip mulch in parks and gardens. Common examples include Psilocybe cyanescens, P. caerulipes, P. baeocystis, and P. pelliculosa.

Disturbed Land

This category includes areas recently cleared for agriculture or development, gardens, and riparian zones. The latter are areas alongside rivers that are subject to frequent fluctuations in water levels or floods. Psilocybe species found here include P. azurescens, P. cyanescens, P. caerulescens, P. ovoideocystidiata, P. subaeruginosa, and P. quebecensis.

Dung

Dung-loving species grow in manure-enriched pastures or, in some cases, directly on animal dung. They include the Psilocybe species P. cubensis and P. mexicana and Panaeolus species P. cyanescens and P. subbalteatus.

Moss

Moss is not generally a suitable habitat for magic mushrooms, although it may be possible to find Psilocybe baeocystis and P. cyanofibrillosa growing here.

Burned Land

Recently burned land is not a good place to find magic mushrooms. However, as time passes and the land recovers, it may be possible to find species such as Psilocybe strictipes here.

Magic Mushroom Identification Features

There are several other methods of identifying magic mushrooms and telling them apart from their look-alikes. Paul Stamets states that if a gilled mushroom has purple-brown to black spores and bruises blue, it is likely to be a psilocybin-producing species.

Another key identification feature for Psilocybe species, in particular, is being hygrophanous (becoming paler when dried). These fungi also usually have a separable gelatinous pellicle (a thin membrane covering the cap) which can be carefully removed when the mushrooms are fresh.

Growth Patterns

Observing a mushroom’s growth pattern or habit is another way to narrow your search. Some species, such as Psilocybe semilanceata, grow in groups, but each mushroom has a distinct origin point. Mycologists refer to this growth pattern as “gregarious.”

On the other hand, many wood lovers, such as Psilocybe azurescens and Psilocybe cyanescens, grow in large clusters. In this case, several mushrooms may have the same point of origin. Mycologists refer to this growth pattern as “cespitose.”

Blue Bruising

Psilocybin-containing mushrooms often bruise blue when damaged or handled. Some also display bluish discoloration naturally as they age. This is due to a reaction that occurs when psilocybin is exposed to oxygen. It is a useful way to determine whether a mushroom contains psilocybin.

However, some mushrooms that do not contain psilocybin may appear or bruise blue (for example, some Stropharia species and boletes). Therefore, this feature cannot be relied upon in isolation.

Furthermore, the bluing reaction breaks down psilocybin and reduces the mushroom’s potency. Therefore, it is best to handle magic mushrooms carefully and keep bruising to a minimum.

Physical Characteristics

If you find what you believe is a magic mushroom, you must confirm its identity by carefully observing its physical characteristics.

Cap

Pay attention to the size, shape, and color of the cap. Bear in mind that these features can change significantly as a mushroom matures. For example, many magic mushrooms start with a more convex or conical-shaped cap, which flattens out with age.

Many Psilocybe species are umbonate, meaning they have a raised “nipple” in the center of their caps. They also tend to have a separable pellicle and be hygrophanous, lightening in color as they dry.

Stem

Observe the length, diameter, and shape of the stem. Is it straight or curvy? Is it smooth or rough? Does it have an annulus (ring)? Is there mycelium attached, and does it bruise blue when handled? These features can help identify magic mushrooms and distinguish them from their poisonous look-alikes.

Gills

Look at the color and arrangement of the gills. Are they narrowly or widely spaced? Are they attached to or free from the stem? Magic mushroom gills can often become stained with spores as they age, giving them a dark or mottled appearance.

Spores

Making a spore print (see below) is one of the best ways to tell magic mushrooms apart from their look-alikes. Psilocybe species tend to have dark purplish-brown spores, while Panaeolus spores are black.

Magic Mushroom Identification Checklist

The following checklist summarizes the information above. If you find a mushroom you suspect may be psychedelic, asking the following questions can help you confirm its identity quickly, confidently, and safely.

1. 1. Does the mushroom grow in this area?
   2. Does the mushroom grow in this habitat?
   3. Is it the preferred growing season for the mushroom?
   4. What is the mushroom’s growth pattern?
   5. Do the mushroom’s cap, stem, and gills match its description?
   6. Does the mushroom have a separable gelatinous pellicle?
   7. Does the mushroom bruise blue?
   8. What color are the mushroom’s spores?

Making Spore Prints

To make a spore print, collect a specimen by carefully pulling it up or cutting the base of the stem.

At home, prepare some paper for your spore print. It is best to use a sheet of white paper and a sheet of black paper and stick them together with tape. This will allow you to observe the spore color irrespective of whether they are light or dark.

Cut the stem off the mushroom as close to the cap as possible. Then, place the cap, gill side down, on the paper. It should sit so that half of the gills are on the black and half are on the white side.

Cover the mushroom cap with a glass and leave it overnight. By the morning, it should have produced a visible spore print.

It is good practice to spore print every specimen you intend to consume. This is because magic mushrooms and their poisonous look-alikes can sometimes grow side by side and be very difficult to tell apart.

Magic Mushroom Look-Alikes

As mentioned earlier, most magic mushrooms are small, brown, and have many potential look-alikes. Some of these look-alikes can be deadly. For this reason, it is essential not to rely on one feature alone when identifying magic mushrooms. And if you are in any doubt whatsoever about a mushroom’s safety, do not consume it.

Wood Lover Look-Alikes

Galerina Species

Deadly poisonous Galerina mushrooms, such as G. autumnalis and G. marginata, resemble wood lovers like P. azurescens, P. cyanescens, and P. stuntzii. These mushrooms also grow in similar habitats, sometimes occurring alongside one another.

Galerina mushrooms grow in groups or clusters on decaying wood or moss. They have brown caps and short, brittle stems that darken from the base. Some people may mistake this darkening for the bluing reaction that occurs in some psychoactive species.

The best way to differentiate Galerina species from magic mushrooms is to make a spore print. Galerina spores are rusty brown rather than purplish-brown or black.

Pholiotina Species

Pholiotina filaris is another deadly species that may be mistaken for magic mushrooms. It grows in woodchips and is widespread throughout the Pacific North-West and Europe. It has brown caps that are conical when young, becoming flattened and umbonate with age.

Like Galerina mushrooms, Pholiotina filaris produces rusty brown spores. Therefore, making a spore print is the best way to identify this mushroom species.

Hypholoma Species

Hypholoma mushrooms are another poisonous magic mushroom look-alike. Although rarely deadly, they can cause severe vomiting, diarrhea, and seizures. They are brown or yellowish and grow in clusters on decaying wood.

It is tricky to differentiate these mushrooms from magic mushrooms because they can have purplish-brown spores, like Psilocybe species. Therefore, for identification, it is essential to rely on other features, such as physical characteristics and blue bruising.

Oceanic and Grassland Species Look-Alikes

Protostropharia semiglobatus

Protostropharia semiglobatus is a species that may be mistaken for Psilocybe semilanceata. They grow in the same habitat and can even be considered an indicator species, meaning that magic mushrooms may grow nearby.

These mushrooms are not deadly but are not considered edible either. Furthermore, they are not psychedelic, and picking them by mistake may result in disappointment. Fortunately, the mushrooms look quite different once you know what to look for. P. semiglobatus is yellowish and tends to be rounded rather than conical, like P. semilanceata. However, it does have dark purplish-black spores, which may cause confusion.

Psathyrella Species

Psathyrella mushrooms may be mistaken for grassland species such as Psilocybe semilanceata. It is a large family, and the various species have differing appearances. However, some do bear a striking resemblance to these magic mushrooms. They have dark spore prints, and the caps can be hygrophanous, like many Psilocybe species.

One distinguishing feature is that the stems of these mushrooms are fragile, hence their common name, brittle stems. Conversely, Psilocybe mushrooms tend to have tough stems that can bend significantly without breaking.

Panaeolus Species

Some Panaeolus species are magic mushrooms themselves and can be found growing in manure-rich pastures or on dung. People foraging for Panaeolus mushrooms could mistake other non-psychoactive varieties in the genus for psychedelic ones as they look somewhat similar. These fungi might also be confused for Psilocybe semilanceata.

Dung Lover Look-Alikes

Stropharia Species

Stropharia species are little brown mushrooms that grow on dung, wood debris, leaf litter, and grass. They share many features with Psilocybe mushrooms, including a purple-brown spore print. Some can also display bluish tones that may be mistaken for blue bruising.

These mushrooms are so similar to Psilocybe that, historically, there has been some taxonomic crossover between the two genera. However, they are now recognized as distinct, highlighting the importance of considering all characteristics when identifying magic mushrooms.

Deconica

Like Stropharia, Deconica mushrooms were once classified alongside Psilocybe but are now recognized as a separate genus. However, they share many similarities, including their purple-brown spore print. They grow on dung and could easily be mistaken for Psilocybe cubensis. Therefore, careful identification is necessary to tell the difference between these fungi.

Agrocybe

Agrocybe mushrooms can look similar to some Psilocybe species, such as P. cubensis, and they grow in similar habitats, including dung. However, these magic mushroom look-alikes can be differentiated by their spores, which are brown rather than purplish-brown.

Magic Mushroom Foraging: Laws, Ethics, and Etiquette

Foraging for magic mushrooms is a wonderful way to connect with nature and learn more about how these fungi grow. However, it is essential to be safe and respectful and avoid breaking the law.

Safety

As well as ensuring you identify foraged mushrooms correctly, you should only harvest them from unpolluted areas. Mushrooms are bio-accumulators, meaning they readily absorb any chemicals in their surrounding area. Therefore, picking mushrooms from roadsides or habitats like parks and farmland where pesticides may have been used is inadvisable.

It is also essential to remain safe while consuming magic mushrooms. Their effects can be unpredictable, and even experienced psychonauts may be taken by surprise on occasion. Therefore, it is crucial to ingest mushrooms in a safe and controlled setting and prepare adequately for the trip, including knowing about potential adverse effects.

Furthermore, some mushrooms can cause unexpected side effects. For example, wood lovers paralysis is a phenomenon that some people experience after using Psilocybe cyanescens, P. azurescens, or P. subaeruginosa. It involves a temporary loss of muscle function, usually toward the end of a trip or the following day. While it does not appear to cause long-term complications, wood lovers paralysis can be frightening and may be dangerous if it occurs while outdoors.

Respect

When foraging, respecting the environment, the landowner, and other people is essential. This means getting permission to forage in the area, not causing any damage or littering, and not taking more mushrooms than you need.

It is considered best practice to leave a minimum of 30% of the fungi behind to maintain the population for subsequent years. Avoid picking mushrooms that have not fully opened and released their spores, and try to confirm their identity before harvesting.

Legality

Psilocybin is still a federally illegal substance, and foraging magic mushrooms is prohibited in most places.

The situation is slowly changing with a growing trend for decriminalization. However, we recommend that would-be foragers thoroughly research the laws in their area before picking magic mushrooms in the wild.

It is also essential to note that foraging, in general, is not permitted in many national parks, and permission should be sought before searching for mushrooms on private land.

Identifying Magic Mushrooms: Final Thoughts

Foraging for magic mushrooms is a fun and rewarding pastime, but it is not without risk. Many magic mushroom species have poisonous look-alikes; some are potentially deadly.

Therefore, individuals must know how to identify magic mushrooms correctly. This includes paying attention to when and where they grow and their physical characteristics. It is also important to use multiple features for identification rather than relying on just one or two.

There is an adage in the mycology world: “if in doubt, throw it out.” This is particularly relevant regarding little brown mushrooms like Psilocybe and Panaeolus species. However, we suggest that “if in doubt, don’t pick it in the first place” is a more sustainable sentiment.

Now that more and more places are decriminalizing psilocybin, individuals in these locations may be better off purchasing magic mushrooms online or growing their own. Doing so will not only offer increased safety. It will also help to protect wild mushroom populations for generations to come.

THERE’S NO CAP ON YOUR STUDY OF MUSHROOMS!

If you truly want to learn more about different mushroom strains, check out the full Fungushead spore range. The Psilocybe cubensis species is well represented, with the brand’s collection including golden teacher, penis envy and B+ spores. The more you learn about these magical mushrooms, the more you’ll realize how remarkable they are. Fungushead accepts various payment methods, including cryptocurrency, and legally ships its spores to 47 American states.

Visit Official Site